Abstract & Overview
My aim in this thesis is to reveal the true nature of mathematical reasoning and to show the necessity of pictorial representations in mathematics. In order to support my thesis I argue that using only the formal language, without fully integrating visual reasoning in mathematical communication, mathematics operates insufficiently and it can never reach its full potential. First of all, I provide a short historical approach to philosophy of mathematics as well as a summary of current state of visualization in mathematics. Then, I bring forth a complete picture of philosophy of mathematics and mathematical objects, which consistently allows visual reasoning, intuitions and constructions in mathematical communication. This interpretation makes it easy to see the pictorial representations as a natural part of mathematical reasoning. Moreover, I lay out the medium for visual reasoning in mathematics: Space. After providing several definitions of space I conclude that Kant’s characterization is the finest one as a base for mathematical reasoning, in particular for visual reasoning. Furthermore, I bring out the method of visual reasoning: Synthetic a priori. In order to show the link between visualization and synthetic a priori I provide hitherto definitions of visualization and argue that these lead up to Kantian characterization of constructions and synthetic a priori. Then, I provide several interpretations to show that Kant’s characterization of mathematics has elements valuable for modern mathematics that modern logic cannot capture. Finally, I offer three main arguments leading to the main thesis “pictorial repre- sentations/ diagrams are necessary parts of mathematical reasoning”: (1) There are formal systems with diagrams. Hence, not all uses of diagrams are synthetic. (2) There are necessary non-formal uses of diagrams in mathematical proofs. (3) There is a strong link between visualization and Kantian philosophy of mathematics. As a result, I claim that the real capacity of mathematics is not in turning it into a machine language but integrating and appreciating the aesthetic part of it as well. I also indicate the necessity of having a theory of diagrammatics, which should be set up as a branch of mathematics.